Sunday, August 20, 2017

#2 - The secod worst, but still a loser

David Fisher. Bill O'Reilly's Legends and Lies: The Real West. Henry Holt, 2015.

Author
David is a journalist, O'Reilly is a jerk.

Benefit
David Fisher and Bill O'Reilly cover the usual laundry list of heroes of the Wild West. There is no attempt to recover the historical character, separating it from legends and lies - as the title would suggest. This book contributes no new research and very little analytical insight into the lives of historical figures, other than what we could expect to find in a Wikipedia article. This is not to say that Wikipedia is inherently a poor source of information. In fact, Wikipedia articles are so good that a book should contribute more to the general discussion than what is common knowledge. As such, this book is a best seller that rides on the coattails of a very popular cable TV show by the same name, but in substance it is completely (not just a little) useless. At the same time, useless drivel can be fun... if you're like me and grew up with stories about American Western folk heroes, this book reinforces those stories rather than challenges them.